"Who's up for a Scary Story contest?" Levy said, while adjusting her witch hat.
"Yes! I'll beat you, Gray!" Natsu exclaimed.
"No. Don't feel like it." Gray put down his drink on the counter.
"Fine, that means I've beaten you already! Erza?"
"Scary Story contest?" Lucy asked.
"Yes, it means that I give the contestants a scary story, and they have to tell it as well as possible. It's an amazing game for a Halloween afterparty. Wanna join?"
"No, no, I'm no good at storytelling. I'll be a judge," Lucy said.
"Okay." Levy sounded a bit disappointed. "Wendy?"
"N-n-no... I'm n-n-not good with scary stories..." Wendy said, shivering in a corner.
"Okay, so you'll be a judge too," Levy said.
"Wh-wh-what?!" Wendy came over to the counter, the tail of her black cat costume between her legs. "O-o-okay..."
"Okay! I only had two stories prepared anyway." Levy exclaimed, happily. "Here are your stories." She handed Natsu and Erza a sheet of paper. "Natsu, you're up first."